CGC experience - mechanical error

I’m neither, I’m Linux.

My world looks like this all day every day…

And yes, Apple sells you pretty utter shit (I hate apple and I hate their products, it’s pretty wrapped around cheap ass hardware you can find elsewhere)… they fool the masses in overpaying for pretty (bravo to them though, it’s made them trillions of dollars). So yes, people love pretty… the world should think differently in my opinion cause for me, its about how useful it is, how secure it is and if it just works.

You can save a lot of money by not caring what something looks like. Judge it by it’s function, not it’s looks is always my approach. I use to care what type of car I drive, now I only care about a few things… is it reliable, does it have decent gas mileage, is my maintenance costs low, and living in Texas does it have AC? :wink:

2 Likes

Ultimately I go back to CGC because of the higher market price for the books, when I eventually sell some of the books. I also think CBCS may be a bit too strict with their grading based on overstreet guidelines.

I think it’s more brand loyalty. Cgc has been around the longest.

I like that CGC can grade moderns pretty quickly compared to other companies.

When I was looking to buy my boy’s UF#4, both CGC and CBCS had the same price. It’s just a matter of time before CBCS catches up to CGC.

I do have to agree though, a CGC book does look better displayed…

CBCS will not catch up with CGC since their grading on GA, SA and BA books (and CA and MA for the most part) is not as strict as CGC. You see a lot of whining on the CGC boards that they are too strict now, but they are just going back to grading like they used to in the early days. GA/SA/BA CBCS books tend to get a grade or two lower on resubs even after a press and dry cleaning. There is a noticeable difference now between CGC and CBCS grades, and that is why collectors pay less for CBCS books. If Beckett can get them to tighten things up then CGC will finally have a serious competitor. I doubt it, though, as even though Steve B is a good person his grading guidelines are just as loose now as they used to be towards the end of his time at CGC. There are plenty of CGC slabs from that time and a decent while after CBCS started up that should never be cracked for a press and resub due to horrible over/gift grading.

Third time’s the charm? Sending 5 CGC slabs back for the second time to get the slabs and interior sleeves replaced due to scratches and scuffs on the interior.

Last time they did nothing, or they didn’t replace the interior sleeve which is the issue. This time I’m circling the defects, writing on the slab was the issue is, then attaching a written explanation to each one as well.

Not sure what else to do other then try to get my money back if this doesn’t get resolved.

2 Likes

Sorry, they’re too busy slabbing gimmicks for Bad Idea.

5 Likes

My walkthrough slab for my Young Avengers was fast. The mechanical error correction is taking forever. Sigh.

Or getting the forum members to grade their books for free!

2 Likes

They’re on their way back…given the fast turn around I’m not hopeful they fixed anything….

1 Like

Cgc meeting: So what should we do to keep our reputation and quality control up?
Build more locations
Cut off submissions until we manage to get through our massive backlog
I know! Grading stamps

1 Like

Nothing wrong with diversity. Especially when people realize CBCS is now pumping out a superior product. Gotta fall back on something.

Hallelujah!!!

No scarring or scuffing!!! Clean as a whistle!!!

Finally….now I can write CGC off forever…

Forever….

Forever….

image

3 Likes

Not mine. But mislabeling a newsstand UF4 as a facsimile….?

Whoops.

2 Likes

There is a stark difference in value!

But CGC is the best, they never make mistakes… they’re the all mighty final authority on comics, firsts in comics, etc… I don’t believe it’s not a facsimile because CGC is the BEST!!! :crazy_face:

I saw that posted the other day. Smh what a mess.

It’ll get fixed. Mistakes happen, But just shows how bad they’re quality control is throughout the process.

This isn’t a scratch on a case, label misspelling or a subjective grade.

So many opportunities to have caught this….

Is he selling this? I’ll give him $200 right now. Decent offer if you consider it is facsimile.

1 Like