Online Comic Store Report Card

Got my first variant package back from Villain. Had already grabbed some general releases, but this was the first incentive package and it arrived in perfect condition. Well packaged and secure from the boarded variant to the unbagged main covers.

Villain Gaming Ratings:

:star::star::star::star::star: - Packaging
:star::star::star::star::star: - Communication
:star::star::star::star::star: - Shipping time
:star::star::star::star::star: - Online Ordering/Options (One of the best options if you know you really want a ratio for a certain book. Great variant packages and they’ll add one for you if you ask early enough!)

1 Like

Yeah, this is a big deal and super helpful. For reference, Westfield does this also, so if anyone is just tired of TFAW, Westfield ships within a couple days and only charges once a month(or more if you choose more frequent shipments)

1 Like

Mixed feelings regarding my latest TFAW to be ‘processed’. Shows most being processed except the
Star Wars War of the Bounty Hunters Jabba Hutt #1 (Coello Variant)
Star Wars High Republic Adventures #6 (Cover B - Kyriazis Variant 10 Copy)
Sinister War #1 (of 4) (Ngu Variant)
All were ordered Pre-FOC (Frustrated !), but still happy I got the rest of my order processed (my tax + shipping ~ $50 :frowning_face:)

My previous order came in all damaged, BUT TFAW CS was great to deal with and refunded the charges, after I sent them pics. Honestly, I would have preferred my books in good condition to the refund, but I commend TFAW on trying to make amends. I am hoping their next order is packaged a little better. I did ask the CS if they could use some bubble wrap around their package, a la Midtown, but he mentioned that they were looking into options, and he did mention that they would indicate the ‘Do Not Bend’ on the package. Full disclosure, I did not request bag/boards for my books, because I dont believe, for the added cost, that they offer any significant protection without a stiffer envelope or bubble wrap around it. Midtown handles this much better for the same or lower shipping cost. Hopefully, the ‘Do Not Bend’ indication makes the mail service handle the package better. Still sticking with TFAW in the meantime, hoping they iron out their issues with shipping, packaging, processing time.

I had the same books in my Pre-FOC that were left off the current “processing” order at TFAW. A little concerned, but I did have ratio left off a previous order (even though I received the other ratios of the same book) that got shipped on the next order. I’m hoping that is the case again and that those ratios will be shipped on the next order.

1 Like

TFAW gets 1 out 5 stars from me. I ordered 3 copies of a comic that released in Feb. They shipped one of those to me several months later and another one last week. So I paid $20 for those 2 comics w shipping, which should have been about $6 if included with the rest of my order as it should have been.

Add to that, zero communication, zero response to emails and terrible shipping.

I’ve asked them to clear any of my pending pre-orders, also w no response. If they ship anything else, I will dispute the charge.

I’m hoping the same thing (for all of us). I scramble to get a copy of the variants, feel elated to preorder it, then its a hit or miss whether you’ll actually get it.

1 Like

There’s a chance you might not win that dispute. What you should do is just stop the charge at the bank level (might just have to cancel whatever account/card you have on file and get a new one then it just never succeeds to charge you). Then move on with your life not having to waste your time disputing.

And yes, I forgot to mention that my White 1, First print (early preFOC) was cancelled ! I expected this …sigh ! And my BW 6 !

Pretty much everyone got their order for white cancelled, black mask limited the print run to 2500 so everyone who ordered them got shorted

2 Likes

Blackmask is probably leaking all the extra copies they printed up on eBay… they need more money! :wink:

2 Likes

Villain Gaming :star: :star: :star: :star: :star:

My first order from Villain Gaming. All NM books. I know retailers have a hard time getting Dynamite books in NM condition, so I am very grateful with the Parrillo virgin.

5 Likes

Got my TFAW order in today. All great except they forgot to send me the variant for SIKTC #17. Overall, packaged well with 2 separate bundles in paper wrap.

Also got my Villain Gaming order and all books on NM condition. Thanks @faele

1 Like

Well I have had to use it a few weeks back. An order did not reflect the correct price after checkout and I was over charged. I sent and e-mail explaining the overcharge (On a Saturday even). I was contacted immediately and informed it was a price glitch and it will be corrected. Within minutes I had the money refunded to my account. Shit happens out of ones control…its what you do after, that shows your true character…and this was 5 Star Customer Service!!

3 Likes

Just received my second shipment from Midtown in a few days. Packed great and shipped fast. My Shang-Chi #3 1:50 is beautiful and was shipped in a hard plastic sleeve. From a value perspective everything was priced well (Curse of the Ebony Blade #1 Hans was less than $20). Maybe most important nowadays, hotter books were shipped with no excuses. 5 :star: all around this time, Midtown. Let’s keep it up and I’ll definitely be back!

My ReedPop J. Scott Campbell Rogue negative space variant just came delivered better than I expected from the horror stories. Shrink wrapped with a board. Placed between 2 larger cardboard and placed in a gemini.

8 Likes

I did get Marvel Voices Pride #1 Vecchio 1:25 on my last order.

These still have not processed for me?. Anyone get any of these processed on their last order?.

Amazing Spider-Man Annual #2 (Infinite Destinies)
Black Cat Annual #1 Infinite Destinies (Charest Variant)
Black Widow #7 (1 of 2 shipped)
Barbaric #1 (Cover D -Seeley Polybag Variant)
Brzrkr #3 (Cover C- Grampa Foil Variant)
Extreme Carnage Alpha #1 (Yu Wraparound Variant)
Heroes Reborn #7
Never Never #1
New Mutants #19 (Dauterman Rachel Summers Design Variant Gala)
Nottingham #4
Shang-Chi #3 (Michael Cho Variant) (New release…ship date 7/28/21)

Star Wars War of the Bounty Hunters Jabba Hutt #1 1:25 (Coello Variant) All the regular covers processed. The 1:25 did not?

Star Wars War of the Bounty Hunters #1 (JTC Action Figure Variant)
Venom #35 (200th Issue Mr Garcin Variant)
Venom #35 (200th Issue Jock Variant)
Venom #35 (200th Issue 1:50 (JSC)
Venom #35 (200th Issue 1:100 (STEGMAN)
W.E.B of Spider-Man #1 (1:25 Copy Bagley Variant)
Wynd #7 (Cover A - Dialynas)
You Promised Me Darkness #1 (3rd Ptg)

Barbaric #1 polybag variant was shorted almost 300 copies, I asked C’s about it and that’s what they said. I had my pre-order placed 2 months before FOC for that issue, so they must’ve gotten like none. They are awaiting replacements they said

1 Like

there is no excuse for tfaws continued problems. i know we like them for well priced ratios, but whats the point if they never ship them

Anyone ever buy a slab from tfaw? Saw they had a graded copy of dark ages 1 and decided to order it

If it has DF in the title, it’s Dynamic Forces and you’ll get it in about 30 years… :wink:

5 Likes