He was in 3 or 4 panels of HRA #3. Seemed like a full to me, but I’m sure people will argue about it.
#4 is supposed to have 1st appearances of a couple new Jedi Masters and Padawans and some new villains. Unsure how consequential they will be but its a buy for me.
That’s nonsense… are they seen or known? Then it’s an appearance as well…
If you saw me in the park but didn’t know my name, I still appeared… This whole, “doesn’t qualify” talk is just utter crap… Appearances are exactly that, they appeared. If they aren’t in the book, then they didn’t appear.
Also… If I show up to the meeting via camera (or hologram when they are invented and used) at work, I appeared at the meeting. Physically there is not a requirement to “appear”… Same rules in life can be used in fictional comics.
But if your bosses at work are talking about you and watching a video of your car driving around it doesn’t mean you have made an appearance yet. Maybe your wife is inside the car going to pick up groceries. It’s just an appearance of your car, we don’t know who’s inside. Until you step out, then you have made an appearance.
There was a Star Wars comic a while back. I wanna say High Republic, that had a person appeared in Hologram and people went crazy and called it her/his first appearance. I wanna say Avar Kriss.